Deer Debate: Identical Twins?

No

Nope.

No

No

Brow tines look the same and the spread between end of main beams and the spread between g1s look the same, seems to be the same buck to me.

Seems to line up for me so I'm gonna say it's the same deer

I would like to hear reasoning as to why not however because I must be overlooking something if everyone else thinks no

The tip of the main beam on the right side is different

@Sam that’s the main differentiator to me. I thought it was the same deer at first, definitely a ton of similarities, but pretty convinced it’s a different deer at this point.

No

Both beasts! Get em! Good luck

Nope, probably brothers or father and son lol

Nope

Nope, the tips of both main beams are wider on the first pic, and seems to have more overall mass. Good luck!👍

Nope second deer looks wider and taller.

na

No

Nope

Nope

Nope

No sir! Two monsters

Nope

No

no first one looks like it has more antlers

They are two different deer

No sir

No

Yea

Nope

I would say no. There are. Despite the bad photo noticeable differences in the antler makeup

It does not look like the same deer to me if you look at the rack they are different

No

Left brow time is shorter on one and not the other

No

No its not, look at the left side of the deers the first deer as some bumbs and the 2nd deer dosnt

Different bucks

A case of beer says it ain't the same deer

No

I agree with everyone else. Doesn't look like the same deer to me

I would say no. Looks like same genetics though.

Definitely not

Definitely two different bucks. Both nice!

All I see are shooters! Lol

Nope

Nope.

@Zack you should ask your step dad what he thinks.

No

No

Yup

I’d say no. Father son, yes.

No one has a crab claw

@Isaiah in the first picture, it looks as if it may have a sort of crab claw split on its left main beam, and bladed on the right main beam. The more clear picture shows the beams are clean and straight. I could be wrong, but I think it’s 2 deer

No

Looks the same to me everything lines up

No

@David hahaha he said not the same

Yep

No

Nope. Whited out pic appears to have some slight palmation on the end of right beam. And If whited out deer is looking away, larger brow is on the right. Larger left G2, normal pic the buck has a short g2

Absolutely it's the same buck

@Joe how do you figure its not the same just asking brother

Different. Night time pic you can see stickers on the right side of the deers head(our left). Then the tip of the main beam on our right(the deers left) is more bladed. The 2nd deer is more of a point and no stickers that I can see other than the brow tines.

I think people are getting confused with the different angle, and obviously the quality of the first doesn't help. I think it's the same.

I don’t think so. The antlers don’t look the same. The lower middle spikes look like different sizes.

Nope, brow tines look the same, but the main beam on the first deers right side isn't the same as the second deers right side. Also, the tines on the second deer come together closer on the top then that of the first deer. The deer are very similar, but don't think it's the same deer.

No

💯 No. tip of main beam on one side has a kicker on one buck and not one on the other

I say no, it looks like the first pic deer is looking back toward (no eye glare) the deer behind it which would put the short tine on the opposite side of the second pic deer.

I’m saying no. It’s 2 deer with similar racks.

Several small differences that would not be affected by that angle

Nope on a rope

Nope

Shoot em both

No, one is wider than the other.

Y split on right beam tip

@Nick That's a great description of it. I agree

They could be brothers tho lol

i see two different bucks. the tip of the main beam is different on the first buck. i think looking at it the second bucks tines have a bit more of a rounded out 'bowl' look to them. first buck seems more straight up and down.

Nope two different deer

Nope

I say yes

In my opinion it's pretty obvious that the curvature of the second deers tines are curved more, whereas the first deers tines are a bit straighter.

@Sam AMEN, brother

No. Buck #2 has more curvature. #1 goes more straight up. I wouldn't be surprised if they shared genes though.

No

I would say no just because of the shape/spread of the antlers

Deer 1 tunes are fairly straight, deer 2 has a pretty good curve to the tines. Deer 2 main beams turn up more at the tips.

I say nope

@Ronnie the shape looks different to me. One looks more straight up and the other has more of a curve to it.

I'd say yes they are the same deer.

@Ronnie and the second looks a tad wider.

Same buck

I'd say nah
similar, but different units

Yes. Head is slightly turned in the “flash” picture and more head on in the second. Same brow tines .

It seems different to me.

Yes it's the same deer

@Joe right on

No

@Nick yep I see it now, thank you!

@Nick yep I see it now, thank you!

That's gonna be a a definite yes.brow tine and shear height are dead give aways on this beauty

After careful consideration from this untrained eye I would have to say no because of a variety of reasons but hey that's just little old me talking

Nope

No. The tips of the of the main frame are super different

I do not think so.

Nope. Several differences. 1st pic is facing away and his right side brow tine is longer than his left. 2nd buck’s left side brow is longer than his right. 1st pic’s main beams are crab clawed and bladed. Second pic’s are clean. Take the first one ya can👊

No left main beam on one curves up. Other goes down

I believe so. it's hard cause it's a different camera angle but

I believe so. it's hard cause it's a different camera angle but

Not sure man, looks damn hard to tell a difference

Nope

No

no

Yes

I'd say no looking at the one from the back appears to have a claw on its left side

Overwhelming response, thank y’all for digging into it. I think we settled on them being 2 different bucks. Looking forward to getting after em. Will share any success! Good luck everyone!

Good luck and hope you have a successful harvest.

@Dakotah that’s what I’m seeing. First one has a little extra going on

Definitely not.

The spread is different.

Great deer....and not the same one

Are they from different years

I'd have to agree it's the same deer.

I'd have to agree it's the same deer.

I'm going to say no, because of the kickers off what looks like the g4 on the first one. Also I think the first on has taller brow tines

I'm going to say no, because of the kickers off of what looks like the G4 on the first on. I also think that the 2nd one has shorter brow tines

No way it is the same deer

I don't think they are the same buck.

Well, if you decided it's two different deer, we expect you to prove it. lol

Well, if you decided it's two different deer, we expect you to prove it. lol

Yes

Nope two different ones.

No

Not at all

@Tyson Negative, pictures are 3 days apart in different locations.

@